Finally alive again. Went to a Con for most of the last few days, and didn't really have time to make a second round on Monday/Tuesday.
Results from Last Round!
Sasashima Suisei-B: Reaching a very firm middle ground in B-Tier. Sasashima was praised for the shading done on Abel's Armor. While criticism was drawn to how shiny/plastic he feels at times.
Sata-B: So close to reaching A. Sata sits at a very high B-Tier. Sata was criticized for posing and looking a bit bland while praised for expressions and the comparisons between Seliph and Sigurd.
Sencha-B: Reaching a mid-B rating. Sencha was a split artist last round. Some praise was drawn towards how the coloring was done for the characters while Criticism was at the expressions and posing of the characters.
Seo-C: Reaching a high C-Rating, Seo was praised on being a bit fitting for Lute and how the clothing was drawn while criticized for having pretty strange faces and shading on Lute.
Shimomura-A: Reaching a low-A rating, Shimomura was praised for some of the similar things Sasashima was praised for, armor shading in particular. While some criticism was drawn at how Haar was posed.
The Ratings!
Fantastic Art! S - This rating is reserved for the best of the best artists! These artists really nail a character's design well, even blending in well with the character's personality!
Artists in this tier: Izuka, Kaya8, Kita.
Great Art! A - This Rating is reserved for artists who's art is great for the most part. There might be a bit of quality left out compared to those in S-Rank, but the art still gives a "Wow!" factor.
Artists in this tier: BUNBUN, Asatani, Cuboon, Akira, Fuzichoco, HACCAN, Haimura, Hidari, Homazo, Ito Misei, Kozaki, Maiponpon, Mayo, Meka, nabe, Haru, Okuma, PenekoR, sachie, Shimomura.
Good Art! B - These Artists give art pleasing to the eye, but might have art that might seem a bit off for the character in question once or twice.
Artists in this tier: AKIRA, Amagaitaro, Aoji, Argon, Arai, Chiko, Enkyo, Foo, Fujisaka, HAKO, Hino, Itagaki Hako, Ito Nozi, kawasumi, Kippu, Konfuzi, Kiyu, Kousei, Maeshima, Mendako, Mikuro, Sasashima, Sata, Sencha.
A-OK! C - These Artist provide well done art, but it might come off as a bit too much in line, not being anything too unique to the table.
Artists in this tier: Bthx, Ebilia, Gaou, Ryo, Himukai, Hoshino Lily, Ichiiro Hako, Kusakihara, Kusugi, lack, Miwabe, Miyuu, Mizuno Kana, Okaya, pikomaro, Seo.
Below Average! D - Not to say the art is bad by any case, but it could be giving the characters not the looks they deserve or the art isn't a popular style
Artists in this tier: Kotobuki, Masao
Underwhelming! E - Artists who's art either put the character in a much different negative light or lack the large amounts of details put in the art in different tiers.
Round 18!
Suda Ayaka: Has done art for Lewyn and Naesala.
Takagi Masafumi: Has done art for Clair and Peri.
Shioemon: Has done art for Tailtu.
Ippei: Has done art for both Dorcases, Arden, Garon and Walhart.
Discuss and Rate!
Submitted June 19, 2019 at 06:56PM by monsterfrog2323 http://bit.ly/2IpOWtm
No comments:
Post a Comment